Wednesday, October 14, 2009

TIM ADAMS PINOT GRIS 2009

 - Clare Valley, SA
 - $18-$24
 - Screwcap
 - 12.5%alc

Alongside wineries like the Mornington Peninsula's T'Gallant, McLaren Vale's Joseph and northern Tasmania's Grey Sands and Pipers Brook, Tim Adams is a seriously good maker of Australian pinot gris. The Tim Adams style is all about zip and freshness, with a small amount of residual sweetness adding to the wine's overall character.

This salmon pink pinot gris is fresh yet tight on the nose, with clean scents of lightly spiced lemon zest, baked apples and pear. Smoothly textured, its juicy palate displays more weight and concentration than expected, before finishing with a touch of residual sweetness. It's a rather fat and mouthfilling pinot gris underpinned by notes of pear, but it lacks the flavour definition, drive and acid structure which made its predecessor so great (2008-92pts).

O A fuller, smooth and luscious pinot gris from Tim Adams, but its sensory enjoyment is much more pedestrian than his previous release. Drink to 2010.
88 points


Monday, October 12, 2009

CULLEN CABERNET SAUVIGNON MERLOT 2007

 - Margaret River, WA
 - $34-$43
 - Screwcap
 - 12.5%alc

Guided by the esteemed Vanya Cullen, Cullen is a biodynamic producer whose complex, savoury and long living wines easily rate with the new world's best. I can personally attest to Vanya Cullen paying as much attention to the finer details of wine business management as she does her highly skilled winemaking.

Beautifully lifted and herbal, Cullen's 2007 Cabernet Merlot (67%/33%) opens to an unmistakably regional fragrance of dusted blackberries, cherries and violet partnered by fine-grained, toasty cedar oak. Medium to full in body, its palate shows the well judged balance of rich, soft juicy fruits and structure typical of the blend, going on to further reveal savoury undertones of toasty cedar, dry earth and licorice accentuating its dark plum and cherry fruit core. It's perfectly ripened and vibrant, finishing long and dry with the fine length and seamlessly integrated, natural tannins which so define the Cullen style.

ü+ Flawlessly executed from a ripper vintage, this sits exactly where it should in Cullen's impressive arsenal. It's an ideal younger sibling to the Diana Madeline of immense drinkability. Drink to 2017.
93 points


Saturday, October 10, 2009

PETALUMA

Petaluma may well be the most significant of all Adelaide Hills' wineries, but times have changed for this successful brand, easily recognised by its distinct pastel yellow tone.

I was a huge fan of the times when Petaluma revolved around its core wines of Croser, Hanlin Hill Riesling, Chardonnay, Merlot and the Coonawarra blend. With great regularity all of these wines would deliver exceptional quality, value and longevity for their reasonable asking price.

Today Petaluma's range now contains newer wines such as the super premium Tiers Chardonnay, an Adelaide Hills' based Shiraz and a Viognier, a Botrytis Semillon from Coonawarra plus a late disgorged release of the Croser. In addition to this Petaluma has been experimenting with a number of newer styles, of which, the pinot noir sounds most interesting to me.

A new Petaluma release at today's tasting was a non-vintage Croser, which holds a RRP of $25. Unfortunately the company representative had a bottle at the tasting but it hadn't been refrigerated, so all we could do was look at it. Although it's still 100% Adelaide Hills based it's made in a different style to the vintage. Its dosage is higher and there's more opulence and richness of fruit to appease the every day drinker (or so I'm told). I'll be keeping my eyes out for this, although it hasn't been officially released yet.

If anything the new non-vintage release answers my concerns as to why the standard Croser has seen a slight increase in price. As little as three years ago I remember seeing Croser as low as $26 at retail, but since that time I haven't seen it below $30. You wouldn't want the prestigious vintage release competing price-wise with the introductory non-vintage wine now, would you?

THE WINES
Unfortunately my recent decline in passion for Petaluma's wines will probably continue after this tasting. Apart from the chardonnay that is, which delivered another sensational wine from 2007 which continues the evolution and refinement of one of the Adelaide Hills' benchmarks. The other Petaluma wines seem to lack the longevity and structure of the glory years, especially the Coonawarra and Hanlin Hill. In fact, the last few releases of Hanlin Hill have all come across as more of an earlier drinking, riper riesling in my eyes. The representative on the day was probably the first rep I've had this year who admitted to me that the January heatwave had a considerable effect on their 2009 Riesling. As for the Coonawarra, I would've loved to see more cabernet sauvignon coming through, as the 2007 is only 48%

Croser 2007 ($34)
Light yeast and lemon/grapefruit nose. The palate is clean and fresh in the aperitif style so typical of young Croser, with a framework of sour edged, lemony acids and brisk effervescence providing ample freshness. Shows some underlying savoury complexity. A noticeable step up over the 2006 wine. 90

Petaluma Hanlin Hill Riesling 2009 ($25)
Follows the stylistic blueprint of the last 3 releases, which haven't really been my style. It's rather ripe with light apricot/white peach, orange blossom and lemon marmalade aromas. Its fuller, juicy palate is rather lusciously concentrated for Clare riesling with soft acidity, and should make for good short term drinking. 89

Petaluma Chardonnay 2007 ($40)
Far and away my favourite Petaluma wine of recent years and probably one of my favourite Australian wines full stop. Like the other wines it has seen a stylistic change, moving away from the bolder chardonnay it once was to a more refined, elegant and slightly mineral wine. The 2007 succeeds with a bang. It initially announce toasty cedar/vanilla oak on the nose, but with a little aeration it gives way to mineral accented grapefruit and white nectarine, with restraint, elegance and integration. The palate is rich and creamy, with a beautifully refined, savoury fruit profile overlying mineral tones. Bright, brisk grapefruit-like acids draw it out towards a long, penetrating finish. Outstanding. (full review soon) 95

Petaluma Merlot 2005 ($50)
Ripe and plummy with slight licorice and eucalypt on the nose, but no overt green characters. The warmer year played well here, delivering genuinely ripened cherry and plum fruits with smooth, toasty chocolate oak. It's a very smooth, luscious, faintly concentrated, genuinely Australian merlot with medium weight and a good dusting of powdery tannin. 91

Petaluma Shiraz 2006 ($45)
Basically, still not a fan of this. Its viognier says a big hello on the nose, with a jammy, confit-like expression of ripe, almost baked varietal fruits and dried apricot. The juicy, ripe palate would make a good drink for closer to $20 with a slight lick of well extracted spice, but it finishes a bit tart and astringent. 87

Petaluma Coonawarra 2007 ($55)
Only 48% cabernet sauvignon this year with a good dose of merlot and shiraz thrown in (small amount of petit verdot too I think). Its nose is rather ripe, fruity and verging on meaty, announcing plums, blackberry, licorice and chocolate/vanilla oak. Much to my dislike its cabernet component barely makes an influence. The palate is sumptuous, rich and deep on the juicy mid-palate especially, but its ultra-ripe nuances lack the length, structure and elegance of the best years. 89

Friday, October 9, 2009

BARRATT CHARDONNAY 2006

 - Adelaide Hills, SA
 - $25-$32
 - Screwcap
 - 14.0%alc

Barratt may be recognised as a pinot noir specialist but it's usually Lindsay's chardonnay which I most enjoy. Produced from their Uley vineyard in Summertown (planted in the early 80's and now fully mature), Barratt's Chardonnay typically offers a richly flavoured symposium of fruit and oak.

Openly aromatic, an assertive whiff of creamy, toasty oak overlies grapefruit and white nectarine aromas within Barratt's 2006. In true house style its bold and brassy palate leaves little to the imagination, imposing creamy texture and lusciously rich flavours in a forward manner. There's a faint herbal undercarriage, but it just lacks the acid backbone and overt freshness required for a higher score.

ü This is an earlier maturing chardonnay which falls well within Barratt's stylistic parameters. It would be an appropriate selection for anyone in search of a full, luscious and well proportioned white wine. Drink to 2011.
91 points


FROGMORE CREEK FGR RIESLING 2009

 - Tasmania
 - $20-$25
 - Screwcap
 - 9.5%alc

One of southern Tasmania's largest producers, Frogmore Creek, is perhaps best known for their distinct variations of riesling. Made with more than a passing nod to the medium-sweet wines of Germany, the FGR gets its abbreviated name from the forty grams of residual sugar it contains.

Pungently fragrant aromas of gooseberry, kiwifruit, apricot blossom and lime juice precede a moderately luscious, sweet palate with a reserved yet bright presence of acidity providing just enough structure and balance for this style. It's rather essence-like in a rich and concentrated fashion, entwining musk, blossom and citrus marmalade nuances throughout a pleasantly long finish of persevering sweet notes, marred only by a slight tartness.

O With thanks in part to lower alcohol this is very, very easy to drink, however, I would've preferred to see sharper acids with more cut and shape. Drink very cold with Asian food. Drink to 2013.
89 points


Thursday, October 8, 2009

TIM ADAMS SEMILLON 2008

 - Clare Valley, SA
 - $18-$25
 - Screwcap
 - 13.0%alc

Tim Adams is among a small group of Clare Valley producers achieving consistent results with wooded semillon. After fermentation in new French oak hogsheads, his 2008 Semillon spent a further 5 months in oak.

Its rather pungent aromas of restrained gooseberry, lime and lemon zest show a savoury overlay of grilled nut characters, leading into a smooth and rich palate of well rounded, almost rubbery proportions. With ample depth and luxuriously creamed texture, its juicy, mouthfilling palate delivers a careful balance of soft, gentle melon and herb flavours partnered by pronounced yet agreeable winemaker inputs. Mainly through texture its noticeable oak influence plays, allowing a finely controlled presence of chiselled acidity to command the wine towards an extended finish blessed by enduring notes of tobacco and sour citrus.

ü+ Another skillfully made, superb Tim Adams Semillon with much more flavour and textural interest than one would normally expect from 1 year old Australian semillon. An outstanding example of the oaked style. Superlative value. Drink to 2016.
93 points


Tuesday, October 6, 2009

CURLY FLAT PINOT NOIR 2006

 - Macedon Ranges, VIC
 - $42-$51
 - Screwcap
 - 13.5%alc

Situated in Victoria's cool Macedon Ranges, Curly Flat is a boutique winery whose ultra-chic 2006 Pinot Noir has been receiving a lot of press for all the right reasons.

An ethereal bouquet of genuine pinot sexual attraction greets the nose, laden with musky, perfumed scents of earthy red fruits, currant, game meats, beetroot and cinnamon with a hint of stalky goodness. The palate is absolutely packed with vitality and character, as its seamless marriage of supple, saturated pinot fruit and fine-grained French oak unloads savoury, earthy forest fruit flavours encased in a lively framework of brisk acidity and exotic spice. From within its great depth an undercarriage of meaty garden herb begins to emerge, projecting superb length of fruit onto an already exquisite palate.

ü+ Brilliant, brilliant, brilliant; in every respect. You can happily add my name to its growing list of accolades. Drink to 2015.
96 points


Sunday, October 4, 2009

BAROSSA VALLEY ESTATE E+E SPARKLING SHIRAZ 1998

 - Barossa Valley, SA
 - $43-$61
 - Cork
 - 14.5%alc

For reasons unknown to me BVE's recent E+E wines haven't compared well with those which forged their once supreme reputation. Apart from enforcing the benefits of bottle age for premium sparkling reds, the delicious 1998 E+E Sparkling Shiraz reminds us why this label was once considered a Barossa benchmark.

Holding a flat brick red hue, its appearance foretells a complex bouquet loaded with the clever combination of maturity, freshness and masculine charm which sparkling red enthusiasts so desperately seek. Woody, cigar-boxy, dusted earth and chargrilled capsicum aromas enthrall the nose, leading into a richly flavoured, smooth palate of delightful integration and vitality. It's very sophisticated and dry, pushing forward savoury nuances of cigarbox, cedar, currant and tobacco, which culminate with traces of herbal undergrowth and bitter cocoa.

ü+ A truly mature, complex, dry and savoury sparkling shiraz, which forces me to envision a grandfather reclining in an ornate armchair next to an open fire, smoking a pipe and sipping Cognac whilst reading extracts of Bradman's 1948 Invincibles' Ashes tour as a bedtime story. It's moments like these Australians treasure. Drink now.
94 points


Saturday, October 3, 2009

SHAW AND SMITH M3 CHARDONNAY 2008

- Adelaide Hills, SA
- $35-$49
- Screwcap
- 13.5%alc

After a trio of faultless wines from 2005 (94pts), 2006 (95pts) and 2007 (95pts), Shaw and Smith is now firmly entrenched as a front runner among Australia's chardonnay class. At $40 a bottle the M3 is around half the price of many of its direct competitors.

Funky and complex, Shaw and Smith's 2008 M3 presents a lively fragrance of nectarine, peach, cumquat, melon, spice and paw paw aromas, whose perfectly integrated cheesy, leesy notes and fresh nutty/vanilla/butter oak state something of the wild. Without doubt its compelling bouquet is character laden in an artful fashion. Long and shapely, its fluffy palate offers a wonderfully measured intensity of nutty, toasty, white stonefruit and citrus flavour, which is simultaneously fruity and savoury. Sensuously creamed grapefruit/limey acids coat the brimming palate, leaving a lasting impression of brightness and quirky complexity.

ü Absolutely dripping with character, this flawless chardonnay is a magnificent wine in every sense. Drink to 2014.
92 points


Friday, October 2, 2009

LEEUWIN ESTATE ART SERIES SHIRAZ 2007

 - Margaret River, WA
 - $33-$45
 - Screwcap
 - 14.0%alc

Margaret River shiraz is a bit like Advanced Hair's hair loss treatment for men with hair; it's a little misunderstood, perhaps not even that popular, but it's always there if you need it. In defense of the style there's been a couple of handy wines from the excellent, very early 2007 vintage which have been altering my perceptions.

Lightly spicy, with a well composed expression of redcurrant, cherry and blueberry aromas, the 2007 Art Series' balanced nose reveals a smart influence of French vanilla oak alongside funky undertones of fennel. Medium-bodied, soft and approachable, its genuinely ripened choc-raspberry flavours are bound by sweet oak/fruit edges which altogether contradict its more inviting nose, but it contains enough poise, harmony and concentration to please.

O Vigorously ripened and plush, this is a generously fruited, sweetly oaked red of immediate consumer appeal, which doesn't really play to the strengths of what Margaret River shiraz can achieve. More spicy finesse, tightness and elegance would've gone a long way here. Drink to 2015.
89 points